Now let’s get to the real meat and potatoes: what I think caused last night’s bloodbath.
THE IRAN WAR: Presidents going back decades have warned about Iran, but Trump gambled here, and politically, I think that gamble failed spectacularly. Trying to argue that this wasn’t really a “war” only made the optics worse. When Americans are watching a war unfold and feeling its effects at home, arguing over what to call it isn’t going to win them over.
EPSTEIN: Holy good God. This was an issue Republicans talked about endlessly, promising transparency and accountability. Then came documents, controversy, and a whole lot of expectations that were never satisfied. Whatever you believe about the underlying allegations, politically this became another case of promising voters answers and leaving them wondering where the accountability was.
ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION: Republicans promised a massive change in immigration enforcement. In my opinion, they simply didn’t deliver enough of what their own voters expected. Replacing Greg Bovino was also a terrible political decision.
THE PRICE OF LITERALLY EVERYTHING: Blame Biden. Blame Trump. Blame Congress. Blame whoever you want. At the end of the day, people vote based on what life actually costs them. If I can’t walk out of the grocery store without spending $100, telling me how wonderful the economy is isn’t going to make me feel better. And telling Americans they should be willing to tolerate astronomical gas prices because of Iran is politically braindead.
THE SAVE AMERICA ACT: What an absolute disaster. Don’t even get me started.
And here’s the part Republicans can’t escape: the GOP controlled the Presidency and both chambers of Congress.
I’m not putting all of this on Trump. Not even close. Thune deserves his share of the blame. So do the neocons and the Republicans who had power, promised change, and then failed to deliver it.
Last night wasn’t caused by one issue. It was the bill coming due for a whole collection of them.
And if there’s one lesson I’d take from all of this, it’s the same one I’ve believed for a long time:
